29 August 2016 | Online since 2003

25 January 2012|Director of Policy

Director of Policy report - 24th January 2012

Farming Minister Jim Paice announced in Brussels on 10 January that 32 caged production sites in the UK are not compliant with the EU’s Welfare of laying hens Directive. Reports in the media about the UK’s non-compliance are a concern given the efforts by the industry to push the EU Commission, UK government, food retailers and manufacturers to ban imported non-compliant egg from other EU states.

The announcement of possible infringement proceedings being taken by the EU against the UK government for non-compliance coincides with BEIC taking the first steps in a Judicial Review against Defra for its actions in not banning non-compliant imports. In both cases, Defra will be receiving letters as a first step of both legal actions, the timing of which cannot be helpful to the case for Judicial Review. Defra is confident that the non-compliant units, which it claims houses 423,000 birds, will be depopulated by February and once that is done the industry can focus again on non-compliant imports. It is hoped that the Commission will drop infringement proceeding, leading to fines, as soon as Defra can confirm that we are compliant with the Directive.

Including the UK, 15 EU states reported to the EU’s Standing Committee on the Food Chain and Animal Health that they had non-compliant producers. These states were Belgium, Bulgaria, Cyprus, France, Greece, Hungary, Italy, UK, Latvia, Malta, Netherlands, Poland, Portugal, Spain and Romania. Some of these countries, such as Italy and Belgium, admit to having 30% of illegal production. The Commission estimates that 14.3% of EU production (47 million hens) is currently illegal.

AHVLA is – quite rightly - concentrating on closing down illegal production in the UK first before dealing with illegal imports. Working with local authorities, prosecutions will be enforced depending on the mitigating circumstances at the site concerned. After 21 January UV checks on imported egg will take place in earnest and I hope to witness these checks in person with local inspectors.

While the Member State declarations made at the Brussels meeting on 10 January were embarrassing for the UK egg industry, it did at least provide data on all the illegal sites across Europe. So AHVLA now has a full list of every illegal production site and contact details in the Member State concerned so that it can easily cross-check against suspect shipments being imported into the UK.

Alongside the Judicial Review, there are many other initiatives which are being considered by the Chairman and your Council to assist in identifying and prosecuting those importing and using non-compliant egg. In a fast moving political environment, it is important that decisions made on naming and shaming, or rewarding those providing information on illegal imports, are carefully considered. I will report on these initiatives in more detail on the website after the 24 January Council.



25-01-2012 16:55 PM | Posted by: Anonymous
All very well but You fiddle and waffle while the Free Range Producer is still getting totally un-realistic prices for the Eggs he produces.
I thought your remit would be to obtain a fairer price from the Packers/supermarkets.
I think you are in serious danger of totally missing the point.

25-01-2012 22:49 PM | Posted by: Anonymous
Come on Robert we know all this
When are you going to start directing some policies that are going to help the plight of the FREE RANGE producer whose businesses are currently being crippled by unsustainable egg prices that are being kept low by the monopoly operating in the egg industry even though there is now a chronic shortage of eggs still no price increases!!
You need to start firing the ammunition and earning your salary

29-01-2012 20:09 PM | Posted by: Anonymous
Now is an ideal opportunity to promote UK free range eggs as the cage sector is in disaray,

We must reassure consumers that UK free range eggs are the best option and affordable and are produced with no cages, albeit enriched or not in sight.

To hear that major packers are cascading free range eggs into enriched at this time means our marketing of free range isnt working.

To post comment without approval login or register

Display name

Please enter your name

Email (optional)

Please enter your comment

Post Comment

Your comment submitted successfully.Please wait for admin approval.

Some error on your process.Please try one more time.

Related Companies